Debarking a Dog: What It Is, Risks and Alternatives

Key takeaways

  • Debarking is surgery that softens the bark but doesn't stop barking.
  • The AVMA strongly discourages it except for medical reasons.
  • Risks include pain, pneumonia and airway scarring.
  • It's banned for non-medical reasons in several US states and the UK.
  • Treating the cause of barking works better and is safer.

Debarking, also called devocalization or bark softening, is surgery under general anesthesia that removes part of a dog's vocal folds. It makes the bark quieter and lower, but it doesn't stop a dog from barking, and the bark can come back.1,2 It also doesn't treat the reason the dog barks, which is often boredom, fear or separation anxiety.1,3

The American Veterinary Medical Association strongly discourages debarking except for medical reasons. Risks include:2,1

  • Pain after surgery and the risks of anesthesia
  • Bleeding, swelling of the airway, infection, coughing and gagging
  • Aspiration pneumonia
  • Scar tissue that can narrow the airway

It's banned except for medical reasons in Maryland, Massachusetts and New Jersey, and in the UK.1 Before considering surgery, work with your vet to find the cause and use reward-based training. See how to stop a dog from barking.3,4

If your dog has been debarked, see a vet if he:

  • Has noisy breathing, struggles to breathe, or collapses. Go to your vet or an emergency clinic right away.1
  • Tires quickly on walks, or can't cope with heat. These can be signs of scar tissue, so book a vet visit soon rather than waiting.1
  • Bleeds, or coughs or gags a lot, after surgery1

What the Research and Guidelines Say

  • Scarring is a real risk. An AVMA review calls scar tissue and narrowing of the airway a "substantial risk." Both figures come from the same surgery done for medical reasons: one report found scarring in 14% of dogs after surgery through the mouth, and in a study of dogs with laryngeal paralysis, 24% needed a second operation.1
  • The bark can come back. If only the edge of the vocal fold is removed, a near-normal bark may return within months.1
  • Veterinary groups oppose it. The AVMA strongly discourages non-medical debarking. The American Animal Hospital Association and the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association oppose it too.2,1
  • Barking is a common complaint. In surveys, 11% to 13% of owners named barking as a concern.1

What Debarking Surgery Involves

The vet removes some or most of the vocal folds while the dog is under general anesthesia. There are two approaches:1

  • Through the mouth: less invasive and less expensive
  • Through an incision in the throat (ventral laryngotomy): more invasive and costly, but it may scar less often, based on one study of dogs with laryngeal paralysis

Removing more of the vocal fold makes it less likely the bark comes back.1 Even after surgery, the dog still tries to bark, because the reason for barking hasn't changed.1 Some dogs need the same surgery for medical reasons, such as laryngeal paralysis, an airway blockage or cancer.1

Side Effects and Risks

  • Short-term: pain, bleeding, swelling of the airway, infection, coughing and gagging1,2
  • Aspiration pneumonia, from inhaling food, water or saliva1
  • Scar tissue (webbing) that narrows the airway. Signs include noisy breathing, trouble breathing, tiring easily, heat intolerance and collapse. Scarring may need more surgery.1
  • Anesthesia risks, as with any surgery1
  • A false sense that the problem is fixed, while the dog's boredom, fear or anxiety goes untreated1

Is Debarking Legal?

  • Maryland, Massachusetts and New Jersey ban debarking unless a vet decides it's medically necessary.1
  • Pennsylvania allows it only when done by a licensed vet under anesthesia.1
  • California and Rhode Island bar landlords from requiring it.1
  • New York: the State Senate passed a bill to ban debarking for convenience in 2025 and again in May 2026. As of October 2026, it was on the Assembly's floor calendar but hadn't passed the Assembly or become law.5,6
  • The UK forbids it except for medical treatment, and the European Convention for the Protection of Pet Animals lists it among surgeries banned for non-medical reasons.1

Laws change, so check your state and local rules.

Alternatives to Debarking

  1. See your vet to rule out pain, illness or, in older dogs, cognitive decline.3,7
  2. Find the type of barking: alarm, attention, boredom, fear or separation anxiety. Each has a different fix.3,8
  3. Remove triggers, such as a view of the street, and give more exercise and food puzzles.3
  4. Teach and reward a "quiet" cue, and don't reward barking with attention.3,9
  5. Treat anxiety, with training and, if your vet recommends it, anti-anxiety medicine. See dog anxiety.10,11
  6. Get help from a veterinary behaviorist or reward-based trainer.4,8

Bark Collars: Citronella, Shock and Ultrasonic

Bark collars spray, shock or make a sound when a dog barks. The ASPCA calls them punishment devices and not a first choice, and veterinary groups advise against aversive tools such as shock and spray collars. Many dogs learn to bark only when the collar is off.3,12,4 They're especially unsuitable for barking from fear or anxiety, which they can make worse.3,4

  • Citronella spray collars: release a puff of citronella-scented spray when the dog barks. In a small 1996 study (9 dogs, 8 finished), all 8 owners said the spray collar cut barking, half said the shock collar had no effect, and most owners called the spray more humane. They're still a punishment device.13,1,12
  • Shock collars: two UK studies looked at remote shock collars used for recall training, not bark collars. In one, shock-trained dogs were tense more often and explored less than reward-trained dogs. In the other, reward-trained dogs responded to "come" and "sit" more quickly and needed fewer commands.14,15
  • Ultrasonic devices: the ASPCA says collars that make a noise don't work for most dogs.3

If you're considering a citronella collar, talk to your vet or a reward-based trainer first. Don't use one for barking from fear, anxiety or compulsion, and don't use it in a home with other dogs, because another dog's bark can set it off. Use it alongside training that rewards quiet, not instead of it.3,13

See also dog behavior problems.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is debarking a dog?

Surgery that removes part of the vocal folds to make the bark quieter.

Can a debarked dog still bark?

Yes. The bark is softer and lower, and it can return over time.

Is debarking cruel?

The AVMA strongly discourages it, because it's painful, risky and doesn't fix the cause.

Is debarking illegal?

It's banned except for medical reasons in some US states and in the UK.

What are the side effects of debarking?

Pain, infection, aspiration pneumonia and airway scarring that can make breathing hard.

Ask Our Team a Question

Help Others by Sharing Your Dog Health Related Question or Story!

Have a Question, Request or Want to Share a Story that could help others? Our team will answer questions for free!

Please include information such as your dog's medical history, age, sex, breed, symptoms, diet, changes in behavior and medications. Providing pictures by uploading them below can also be of help.

We will do our best to get back to you quickly (it depends on how many questions we receive each day). If you do require an immediate response we suggest using this online dog veterinary service that is available now.

[ ? ]

Upload 1-4 Pictures or Graphics (optional)[ ? ]

 

Click here to upload more images (optional)

Author Information (optional)

To receive credit as the author, enter your information below.

(first or full name)

(e.g., City, State, Country)

Submit Your Contribution

  •  submission guidelines.


(You can preview and edit on the next page)

Sources and further reading

This article was rewritten and fact-checked on October 27, 2026 against current veterinary references and specialist guidelines:

  1. AVMA Animal Welfare Division. Welfare implications of canine devocalization (literature review). American Veterinary Medical Association, March 7, 2023.
  2. American Veterinary Medical Association. Canine devocalization. AVMA policy, accessed October 2026.
  3. ASPCA. Barking. ASPCA, accessed October 2026.
  4. American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior. Position Statement on Humane Dog Training. AVSAB, 2021.
  5. New York State Senate. Senate Bill S3026: Restricts the performance of surgical devocalization procedures on dogs and cats. 2025-2026 legislative session, bill status accessed October 2026.
  6. New York State Assembly. Assembly Bill A8551: Restricts the performance of surgical devocalization procedures on dogs and cats. 2025-2026 legislative session, accessed October 2026.
  7. Landsberg G. DISHAA Assessment Tool (canine cognitive dysfunction checklist). CanCog Technologies; hosted by Morris Animal Foundation, undated, accessed October 2026.
  8. RSPCA Australia. My dog is barking excessively, what should I do? RSPCA Knowledgebase, updated March 2023.
  9. Landsberg GM. Behavior Problems in Dogs. Merck Veterinary Manual (pet owner version), reviewed February 2018, updated April 2026.
  10. ASPCA. Separation Anxiety. ASPCA, accessed October 2026.
  11. Merck Veterinary Manual. Common Drugs Used to Treat Behavior Problems in Dogs (table). Merck Veterinary Manual, references accessed September 2025.
  12. British Small Animal Veterinary Association. Aversive training methods (position statement). BSAVA, reviewed 2024.
  13. Segelken R (reporting Juarbe-Diaz SV, Houpt KA. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc 1996;32). Study: 'Nuisance-barking' dogs respond best to citronella spray collars. Cornell Chronicle, June 6, 1996.
  14. Cooper JJ, Cracknell N, Hardiman J, Wright H, Mills D. The Welfare Consequences and Efficacy of Training Pet Dogs with Remote Electronic Training Collars in Comparison to Reward Based Training. PLoS ONE 2014;9(9):e102722. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0102722
  15. China L, Mills DS, Cooper JJ. Efficacy of Dog Training With and Without Remote Electronic Collars vs. a Focus on Positive Reinforcement. Front Vet Sci 2020;7:508. doi:10.3389/fvets.2020.00508

About this article

Last updated : rewritten using the AVMA devocalization policy and 2023 literature review, ASPCA, AVSAB and BSAVA guidance, New York legislative records and studies published 1996 to 2020.

This page is for general information and is not a substitute for an exam by your veterinarian.